Best Ice Cream Shops in Emerald Isle, NC
A beach day in Emerald Isle isn’t complete until someone in the car says, “Can we stop for ice cream?” Lucky for you, this stretch of Bogue Banks has more ice cream options per mile than almost anywhere else on the Crystal Coast. From hand-dipped scoops to soft serve and homemade fudge, here are the spots worth pulling over for.
Top Ice Cream Shops in Emerald Isle
Village Ice Cream & Candies
This is the one most Emerald Isle regulars think of first. Village Ice Cream & Candies at 9104 Coast Guard Road carries over 40 flavors of hand-dipped Blue Bell ice cream, plus Dippin’ Dots, soft serve, Belgian waffles, ice cream nachos, fresh fudge, and saltwater taffy. The shop is family-owned and has been a summer staple for years. Expect a line out the door on hot July evenings, but it moves fast. The ice cream nachos - waffle chips with scoops and toppings - are a fan favorite that you won’t find at most shops.
The Sweet Spot
Known for its colorful rocking chairs out front, The Sweet Spot serves a wide variety of ice cream flavors, milkshakes, and smoothies. It’s a great stop after a day at the beach access points along Emerald Isle’s oceanfront. The rocking chairs make it easy to sit and enjoy your cone while the kids run around. The milkshakes are thick enough to stand a spoon in.
Ben & Jerry’s Emerald Isle
The Ben & Jerry’s at 8401 Emerald Drive brings the full Vermont lineup to the Crystal Coast. All the classic flavors are here - Cherry Garcia, Half Baked, Phish Food - plus seasonal specials and sundaes. This location is locally owned and operated, not a corporate chain outpost, which means the service feels personal. It’s open seven days a week during the summer season and stays open later than most shops on the island.
Kilwins Chocolate and Ice Cream
Kilwins brings their signature hand-crafted ice cream made with fresh, local cream to Emerald Isle. They’re known for their waffle cones made fresh in the store - you can smell them from the parking lot. Beyond ice cream, Kilwins does fudge, caramel apples, and hand-dipped chocolates. It’s the kind of place where you walk in for a single scoop and leave with a box of fudge too.
Turtley Sweet
Located in Emerald Plantation, Turtley Sweet serves 24 flavors of Hershey’s Premium Ice Cream along with specialty sundaes, milkshakes, and smoothies. The turtle theme is fun for kids, and the portion sizes are generous. It’s a bit off the main drag, which means shorter lines during peak summer weeks.
Rocket Fizz
Rocket Fizz at Village West in Emerald Isle combines candy, novelty sodas, and ice cream under one roof. The soda selection is the real draw here - hundreds of bottles in flavors you’ve never heard of - but the ice cream is solid too. Kids love browsing the candy wall while waiting for their scoop. It’s part ice cream shop, part candy store, part nostalgia trip.
Best Time to Get Ice Cream in Emerald Isle
The lines are shortest before noon and after 8 PM. Between 2 PM and 6 PM on summer days, every ice cream shop on the island is packed with families coming off the beach. If you’re flexible on timing, a post-dinner ice cream run is the way to go - shorter waits, cooler air, and you can eat your cone while watching the sunset.
Most shops are seasonal. Village Ice Cream, Ben & Jerry’s, and Kilwins are typically open from late March through October, with reduced hours in spring and fall. Call ahead if you’re visiting in the shoulder season to make sure they’re open.
Ice Cream After the Beach in Emerald Isle
The best ice cream runs start with a beach day. Spend the morning at one of the beach access points, grab lunch at one of the best restaurants in Emerald Isle, and then hit an ice cream shop on the way back to your rental. Or ride your bike along the Emerald Path and stop for a cone at one of the shops along Emerald Drive.
Ice Cream for the Whole Family on the Crystal Coast
If you’re traveling with kids on Bogue Banks, ice cream shops double as a rainy day backup plan. When the weather turns and the beach isn’t happening, a drive to Village Ice Cream or Kilwins gives everyone something to look forward to. Pair it with a trip to the Salty Pirate Water Park for a full day of non-beach fun.
Whether you’re a hand-dipped purist or a soft-serve fan, Emerald Isle has a shop for you. Just don’t try to rank them - every family on the Crystal Coast has their own favorite, and they’ll defend it loudly.